R&D Tax Credits for Industrial Equipment Manufacturers
If your business builds machines, you may not consider it a research company. But if the machines you’re engineering and building solve problems for customers who need the equipment, or the equipment needs to run faster, last under different conditions, or fit in a space it wasn’t originally designed for, you may fit under the IRC’s definition of research and development.
The tax code looks at whether the work faces a real design question, tests more than one option, and uses scientific principles to answer the question. The four-part test is what will ultimately decide whether the work meets the definition of qualified research under IRC §41.
Why Equipment Makers Often Fit the Credit
A business component is defined as any product, process, computer software, technique, formula, or invention that you hold for sale, lease, or license, or use in your own trade or business (IRC §41(d)(2)(B)). For industrial equipment manufacturers, this could mean the machine you sell, the control software that is developed with the machine, the fixtures your company builds to produce the machine, and the process you use to assemble it.
The Four-Part Test
Each business component must pass the four-part test on its own, not just as one overarching project.
• Permitted Purpose: The activity must be intended to develop or improve the functionality, performance, reliability, or quality of a business component.
• Technological in Nature: The work must rely on engineering, physical or biological science, or computer science principles.
• Technical Uncertainty: The activity must be undertaken to discover information intended to eliminate uncertainty about the capability, method, or appropriate design of the business component.
• Process of Experimentation: Your team must have a process that evaluates alternatives through modeling, simulation, systematic trial and error, or other methods to eliminate uncertainty.
What Might Qualify in Industrial Equipment Work
While this list is not exhaustive, and may not automatically qualify a project for the credit, these are some common qualifying activities that may occur in the industry.
Custom Machine Design and Prototyping
When a customer requires a machine that your company hasn’t yet produced, or for performance standards your current machine line has yet to meet, the question usually comes down to design.
• Structural, thermal, or vibration analysis that compares design alternatives before you commit to one.
• Prototype subassemblies built and tested against performance targets.
• Material and component alternatives tested for wear, weight, heat, or service life.
• Redesigns that follow failures found during testing.
Controls, Automation, and Embedded Software
Machine builders increasingly need to incorporate software along with the machinery they produce and sell. If your company engineers and produces software that ships with your equipment, the software development may also qualify.
• Control algorithms that must hold performance under changing conditions, such as motion profiles, vibration damping, or temperature control, where your team tests several approaches against a target.
• Vision and sensing logic where your engineers compare detection or inspection approaches for accuracy and speed on your own parts and materials.
• System integration with a real unknown, such as getting controls, sensors, and mechanical systems to hit a required cycle time together. Configuring a vendor controller exactly as specified does not count.
Performance Upgrades
Speed, throughput, energy use, and service life improvements to an existing machine design can qualify when there is no clear outcome when you begin the work.
• Mechanism or drive train designs that raise throughput or cut cycle time when the right design is unclear and your team tests alternatives.
• Energy and efficiency improvements where your engineers model and test different approaches to power use, heat, or fluid flow.
What Usually Does Not Qualify
• Configuring a standard machine to a customer’s order. The statute excludes research in which the taxpayer adapts an existing business component to a particular customer’s requirement. If a customer needs a truly customized machine that neither party knows the outcome of ahead of time, there is potential, but a customized standard machine generally will not qualify.
• Quality control and acceptance testing. Routine or ordinary testing or inspection for quality control is excluded from the credit. If the final answer has been reached and the machine is simply being tested to ensure it operates according to standard, it likely won’t qualify.
• Work after the design is ready for production. The regulations treat troubleshooting faults in production equipment, accumulating data on production processes, and debugging flaws as occurring after commercial production begins.
• Following a supplier’s answer. If a supplier tells you which part to buy and your team then tests it to confirm it works as specified, the supplier removed the uncertainty and your testing looks like routine quality control.
• Copying an existing machine. Reproducing a business component from an examination, plans, blueprints, or detailed specifications is excluded, though studying a competitor’s machine while you develop your own does not automatically disqualify you.
• Appearance and style. Research relating to style, taste, cosmetic, or seasonal design factors do not count.
Which Costs Count
• Wages. Wages for employees who perform qualified research, directly supervise it, or directly support it (IRC §41(b)(2)). In an equipment shop, that includes the mechanical engineer running structural analysis on a new frame, the controls engineer tuning motion profiles on a prototype, and the engineering manager who directly supervises that work. Treasury regulations also include a machinist who machines a part of an experimental model used in qualified research as direct support (Treas. Reg. §1.41-2(c)(3)). When 80 percent or more of an employee’s wages go to qualified services, one hundred percent of that employee’s wages count. A design engineer who spends 85 percent of the year on prototype design and testing meets that mark. Below that, you allocate by the time the employee actually spent (Treas. Reg. §1.41-2(d)). A project engineer who splits the year between a new drive design and routine customer support would fall here, so only the time spent on the drive design counts.
• Supplies. Tangible property used in qualified research, other than land and property subject to depreciation (IRC §41(b)(2)(C)). For a machine builder, that means the steel plate, castings, bearings, motors, sensors, and wiring consumed building and testing prototypes, including the material you scrap when a test fails. Equipment you own and depreciate, such as the CNC mill that cuts the prototype parts or the test stand that loads them, does not count as a supply.
• Cloud computing and software. Amounts paid to another person for the right to use computers in qualified research (IRC §41(b)(2)(A)(iii)). For an equipment maker, that can include renting cloud servers to run finite element or fluid dynamics simulations on a new frame design. The regulations require that the computer be owned and operated by someone other than you, sit off your premises, and not have you as its primary user (Treas. Reg. §1.41-2(b)(4)). Software subscriptions and licenses, such as a CAD or PLC programming seats, do not count as supplies, since supplies must be tangible property (IRC §41(b)(2)(C)). Cloud costs that run the business, such as email or a customer portal, do not count either (Treas. Reg. §1.41-2(b)(1)).
• Contract research. Sixty-five percent of amounts paid to non-employees for qualified research (IRC §41(b)(3)(A)). An outside engineering firm that runs simulations on your new frame, or a testing lab that runs fatigue tests on a redesigned weldment, can fit here. A $50,000 invoice from that lab would count as $32,500. The agreement has to pre-date the work, call for research on your behalf, and require you to pay even if the research fails (Treas. Reg. §1.41-2(e)(2)). A fee that depends on the test passing does not meet that last requirement.
Documentation That Holds Up
For an equipment manufacturer, usable documentation may include:
• Name the component. Track time and cost to each machine model, control system, fixture, or process, as well as to the subassembly where the design work happened.
• Document what uncertainty you’re working on. Record what your team didn’t know, and save simulation runs, prototypes, revisions, and designs, whether they were successful or not.
• Show engineering principles. Note the physics, mechanics, or control theory behind tests.
• Mark the production release date. Work after that date falls under the research after commercial production exclusion, so noting it will make sure unqualified work is not counted.
• Separate engineering from build time. Keep design, prototype, and test hours separate from your routine work, as well as the routine production materials.
Courts allow reasonable estimates of expenses, and documentation doesn’t need to be lab-level scientific. If you can connect costs to qualified work, someone familiar with the credit will be able to help you compile a defensible study.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does a custom-built machine automatically qualify for the R&D tax credit?
No, not automatically. Building a machine to a customer’s order doesn’t make the work research. The work qualifies when the method was uncertain at the start and your team works to resolve that uncertainty while testing alternatives.
Do our engineers need advanced degrees?
No. Nothing requires a taxpayer to employ someone with a specialized degree to show technological research. The company still must identify the scientific or engineering principles it relied on, though, regardless of the job title of the person performing the research.
Do factory acceptance tests count?
Generally no. Tests that confirm a machine meets specifications are generally treated as quality control, which doesn’t count.
Do we have to claim the whole machine as one project?
No. If the whole machine does not meet the four-part test, the regulations allow for you to apply the test to the most significant subset of elements, and then to smaller subsets, until you reach one that qualifies.
How Does RK Partners Work With Industrial Manufacturers?
Equipment manufacturers have the engineers doing the technical work, but compiling a defensible study with all the records required can seem overwhelming. RK Partners starts with the documentation, with our CPAs and engineers interviewing engineers and others who worked on the project, knowing exactly what to ask and what to look for to substantiate and support your credit. We handle all the heavy lifting so your team can continue innovating and growing your business.
If your team designs custom machinery, builds controls, develops tooling, or improves equipment to meet an unknown, we are happy to talk through what activities you’re performing that may qualify.


